Skip to Main Content

Life Sciences

  Is it Popular or Scholarly?

Use this table to help determine if your resources are popular (magazines) or scholarly (journals).

 

 

Popular

Scholarly

Purpose:

  • Articles are written to inform or to entertain

 

  • Academic or scientific research articles and information

 

 

Content:

  • Covers broad subjects and topics of general interest
  • Scholarly articles which usually focus on original research in a specific subject field or discipline

 

 

Intended Audience:

  •  Appeal to broad, general readership
  •  Specialized readership; specialists; scholars and professionals in subject field

 

Authors:

  • Magazine staff or freelance writers
  • Experts, scholars, professionals in subject field

 

 

Layout:

  • Most often short articles with illustrations
  • Longer articles, often including tables, graphs, charts

 

 

Style:

  • Non-technical language
  • Technical, specialized terminology

 

 

References:

  • Sources are often not cited or are incomplete
  • Documented research with footnotes and bibliographies

 

 

Review Policy:

  • Reviewed by editor
  • Usually articles are reviewed by a panel of peers; they are often called peer-reviewed or refereed articles

 

Publisher:

  • Published commercially
  • Published by an  association, academic institution or professional organization

 

 

Advertising:

  • Various products and services designed to attract the general consumer
  • Little or no advertising; if present it is usually specific to the field or discipline the journal covers

 

 

Examples:

  • Time
  • Social Work Today
  • Parents Magazine
  • American Spectator
  • Child Development
  • Families in Society
  • Journal of Marriage and Family
  • Journal of Social Issues